Karelia Stetz-Waters reviews From the Boots Up by Andi Marquette

Students often tell me that they want to major in English because they love to read. I am professionally obligated to be happy about this announcement. However, I have reservations. I enjoyed reading more in high school than I did after my two degrees in literature. Mind you I can spot a Shakespearean reference a mile away, but that’s not the same thing as curling up with a good book. Now when I curl up, I immediately start critiquing comma usage. It’s very trying.

That is why I was so pleased to find Andi Marquette’s From the Boots Up.  She has consistently good comma usage!

What? I haven’t sold you on the book yet? Let me try again.

Andi Marquette’s From the Boots Up tells the story of Meg, a hardworking ranch hand, and Gina the L.A. reporter who stays for a week to write a story about Meg’s ranch.  Meg and her father, who owns the ranch, hope the article will drive more traffic to the struggling dude ranch. All Meg has to do is entertain the annoying city slicker for one week. The only problem is that when Gina turns up, she isn’t an annoying city slicker at all.  Meg feels and instant connection to the beautiful and supremely capable Gina, an attraction that she must conceal in order to maintain her professional image at the ranch.

I was immediately hooked, and Marquette held my attention right through to the very end. The main characters are believable and likeable. Their attraction to each other is palpable. The supporting characters are interesting. The subplot (Meg coming out to her father) is as engaging as the main narrative.

What’s more, she makes the novella length work for her. I am not always a fan of the novella. To my taste, some novellas read like underdeveloped novels (or worse yet over-developed short stories). That’s not true here. From the Boots Up is exactly the right length for the story Marquette has to tell. It is qualitatively different from a novel, and it does not want to be a page longer or shorter.

All of this is made possible, of course, by the good writing (and I don’t just mean comma usage). Marquette’s pacing is right on the mark. Her descriptions are vivid. She also does a great job capturing flirtatious banter between the protagonists which is a difficult task. It’s easy for that kind of banter to sound artificial.  It doesn’t here.

Additionally, Marquette can turn a phrase in a way that is poetic without being showy.  Here are a few of my favorites:

She was dressed in jeans that fit her much too well for mixed company and a faded gray T-shirt that hung on her like a best friend.

Gina looked at Meg and a slow smile eased like a summer evening across her face.

Meg’s jaw dropped and the crowd quieted as Gina belted the lyrics in a low-down bluesy voice that could undress you from the next room.

I will definitely check out more of Marquette’s work, starting with Some Kind of River. The only question is whether or not I’ll be able to save it until I get to the beach.

On a side note, I wrote to Marquette with a question about the world of lesbian publishing. She wrote back a very kind and thorough response.  If you happen to pick your books based on the niceness of the author, I would give Marquette two thumbs up in that regard as well. But, you don’t have to take my word for it. Marquette will be appearing at the Left Coast Lesbian Conference in Palm Springs, California, October 9 – 13th 2013.  The conference promises to give readers a chance to mix and mingle with their favorite authors. It looks like fun and you can learn more here: https://www.facebook.com/leftcoastconference.

More about the reviewer at www.kareliastetzwaters.com

3 Replies to “Karelia Stetz-Waters reviews From the Boots Up by Andi Marquette”

  1. Pingback: From the Boots Up | Karelia Stetz-Waters

  2. solargrrl

    Completely agree with your review here,Karelia. By now you may have already read Some Kind of River. I enjoyed that one equally as well. Andi’s writing is excellent. Hope she put out more novella’s as I am a fan of this form of story telling. .