To me, a good short story collection should be like a box of chocolates: cohesive as a whole, but with a variety of flavor and a few surprises along the way. Skin Thief by Suzan Palumbo is an excellent chocolate box of a book. Collecting twelve dark fantasy and horror short stories published between 2018 and 2022, the book weaves together Trinidadian folklore and gothic genre conventions to explore what it means to be haunted and the fluid nature of transformation.
Skin Thief takes its title not from a specific story in the collection, but from an epithet in the collection’s first story, “The Pull of the Herd,” in which is a deer shapeshifter who left her herd behind to live with a human woman must protect her erstwhile family from human men who wish to steal their pelts and trap them as wives or hunt them down like dangerous animals. The story lays the ground for themes that will be explored in the rest of the story—violence and patriarchy, the shifting of shape, the struggle to belong when torn between forms and groups.
I sped through the twelve stories captured in Skin Thief, finding the collection equal parts haunting and absorbing. A sense of tragedy and unease shapes many of the stories, such as “Laughter Among the Trees,” in which a family is haunted by the sudden disappearance of their youngest daughter or “Douen,” following a young girl whose unexpected death is not the end as she is transformed into a lonely spirit who haunts her unaware family. Retelling Trinidadian folklore in several of the stories, Palumbo puts different humanizing spins on stories of malevolent and mischievous spirits, imagining the shock and loneliness of a young girl transformed into a spirit, guilt’s lingering manifestation as a literal haunting, or the allure of the supernatural when you never quite fit in among in a human community.
A number of the stories in Skin Thief star queer women, such as the protagonist of “Kill Jar,” whose isolated upbringing alongside her scientist father is troubled when she begins to question her origins and falls for the daughter of the housekeeper, or “Propagating Peonies,” following a pair of women locked in an entwined cycle of reincarnation. Some of these characters grapple with their sexualities, while in other stories the conflict comes from less mundane sources, such as “Apolépisi: A Descaling” in which a merwoman must come to terms with her lover’s involuntary transformation into a human.
I was impressed by the way that Polumbo’s gathering of the stories together creates a whole which is cohesive and revisits interests and ideas across stories without feeling repetitive when read together. Palumbo explains in the afterward that the stories are arranged in an arc that goes from Canadian settings and dialect at the beginning to Trinidadian settings and dialect, something that represents her evolution as a writer and her identity as a member of the Trinidadian diaspora living in Canada. It’s also a a wonderful example of how stories placed into the broader context of an author’s body of work can obtain an extra level of meaning. While I found Skin Thief to be a quick read, I know that the stories contained within its pages will continue to linger in my mind.
Content warnings: domestic violence, attempted rape, child death, vehicular manslaughter, animal and pet death, body horror




Leave a Reply