Guest Lesbrarian Shanna Shadoan reviews Wildthorn by Jane Eagland

I just read an awesome YA novel.  It’s set in Victorian England, and features a young woman who was committed to an asylum for “moral insanity”.  Basically, she wasn’t behaving in a properly feminine way.  She falls in love with one of the attendants there, so it is a sweet lesbian love story, which is pretty rare in the historical fiction genre!  Anyway, if you’d like to put up my review, here it is!
“‘I told you, that isn’t my name.  I am Louisa Cosgrove. And I’m not meant to be here.  There’s been a mistake.’

He pauses…then turns to read the page of cramped writing I can see inside the folder.

It suddenly occurs to me-perhaps they’re pretending they don’t know who I am. Perhaps they’re trying to drive me mad.

I take a deep breath. ‘I’m not mad, Doctor.  You can see that, so-’”

There’s been a terrible mistake. Instead of being driven to a manor where she was to begin her position as a companion, Louisa is taken to Wildthorn Hall, an asylum.  They call her Lucy and interpret her every protest as further evidence of her illness.  But who had her committed? More importantly, how can she get out? Does her family really believe she belongs here? Or worse, is it possible that they do not even know where she is?

Amidst the groans and suffering of her fellow patients, Louisa recalls her outside life.  True, perhaps she read more than was considered seemly for young women, and her ambition to become a doctor was certainly unconventional.  But moral insanity? Surely having dreams of something other than a husband and family does not amount to an illness!  In order to save her life and be united with her love, Louisa stages a risky escape attempt.  But on the outside, there are many dangers for a young woman, and it seems her troubles have just begun.

I did absolutely nothing today but finish this book; I got it yesterday night.  First, it’s about time we have some good queer historical fiction! Even better, this is a queer story that doesn’t revolve around a coming out. Louisa, from her childhood on, has preferred science to sewing and riding horses to making calls.  However, she is not committed to the asylum because she is a lesbian, rather, because she exhibits unfeminine characteristics and ambitions for her time.  In this way, the book is an interesting commentary on the restrictive expectations for women in nineteenth-century England.

For those of you looking for a love story, don’t worry.  It’s there, it is sweet, and it defies the bleakness of the novel’s setting.  For a young adult book that reads like the lovechild of The Well of Loneliness and Jane Eyre, the tender romance is refreshingly hopeful, but not wildly so.  It is not so perfectly constructed that it seems unrealistic, but it is a lovely surprise!  I’ve been waiting to read this book for a long time, and I couldn’t have ordered a more perfect compilation of everything I love in a read-for-pleasure book. I haven’t been this happy since I discoveredSarah Waters. Oh, and one more awesome thing-this novel is based on a true story (seriously. Isn’t that awful?  We should all be welling over with gratitude for our feminist predecessors, because now we don’t have to worry about being tossed in an asylum because we were inconveniently un-feminine.)

Happy Reading!

3 Replies to “Guest Lesbrarian Shanna Shadoan reviews Wildthorn by Jane Eagland”

  1. caseythecanadianlesbrarian

    This book looks awesome: 19th century England and queer girls? Libba Bray’s Gemma Doyle YA series is also set in the 19th century and features a teenage lesbian character (not revealed until a bit later in the series). It’s also great historical YA fiction, even regardless of the lesbian character!

    Reply

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *